Bok decision needed on Adi

Written by Wesley Weber (wpw)

Posted in :2009 Lions Tour, In the news, Springboks on 22 Jun 2009 at 15:32
Tagged with : , , , , , , , , , , , ,

The series against the British and Irish Lions is there for the taking, but if the Springboks want to be sure of winning the second Test and then have sustained success through the rest of the season, the time has come for the coach to make a difficult decision.

Gavin Rich writes for sport24.co.za:

It has never been a secret that Adrian Jacobs has been one of Peter de Villiers’s favourite players. Jacobs played for De Villiers at the Falcons when he coached there near the start of this decade, and it was De Villiers who brought Jacobs back from obscurity last season to play Test match rugby after a gap of five years.

Jacobs delivered more for the Boks and his coach than many people anticipated last year, and when the matches did open up, he showed great line-breaking ability and was an excellent finisher. While he showed bravery on defence, however, and put in a lot of effort there, the perception that he has a weakness on defence , and is a potential weak link at the back for the Boks, has never really gone away.

Lions assistant coach Warren Gatland, when looking at the strengths and weaknesses of the Boks on the eve of the Durban Test, listed Jacobs’s defence as a potential weakness in his armoury. And this was proved to be the case at Absa Stadium, where the Lions midfield of Jamie Roberts and Brian O’Driscoll did what many suspected would happen last year but didn’t – they exposed Jacobs.

It was almost like someone was calling open gates every time the Lions ran at the Bok midfield. De Villiers has said that he looks forward to working this week on the Bok cohesion on defence, but it would be naive of him to neglect the root cause of the Bok defensive problems – which is that there are now too many players in the backline configuration who do not boast tackling as their strong suit.

It might sound like an odd thing to say on a day when Ruan Pienaar was so outstanding at flyhalf, but the first Test was a game which showed how much the Boks miss Butch James when he is not around. And while Heinrich Brussow was excellent at the breakdown, and should never have been replaced, Schalk Burger’s physical presence on cover defence was also missed.

For all his strengths, Pienaar does not like tackling. He is not like James, who used to relish the physical challenge, and who used to shy the opposition teams away from running at his channel. The Lions are able to run at Pienaar without fear, and they know they can do the same to Jacobs, as they proved when they exploited that channel for their first try in the Durban game.

Jean de Villiers is the best defender of the three, and historically he has been a good defence organiser. You got the impression in 2008 that he did a lot of defending for Jacobs. But De Villiers, who played for so long with two tremendous tacklers on either side of him in James and Jaque Fourie, is not on his own a sufficient physical threat to the opposition on defence.

To compound matters, everyone knows that Jacobs is carrying a shoulder injury at the moment that a few months ago had some medical people recommending an operation. Sooner or later Jacobs is going to have to undergo that operation, and it may not be a coincidence that it is now at least three months, the same amount of time that he has been operating under the injury cloud, since Jacobs really excelled on the field.

It would be okay to continue carrying Jacobs if there were no other centres, but Fourie can deliver the physical threat that Jacobs is incapable of bringing, and a midfield combination of Fourie and De Villiers makes more sense for the Boks moving forward.

It is going to be interesting to see how the Bok coach sees it this week when the team is selected, for if he ignores what was obvious for everyone but himself in Durban (there was widespread shock when he pulled De Villiers, and not Jacobs, from the field) it could risk the Boks losing a Test match.

And against a Lions team that was disappointingly poor in the first game that is just not a result the Boks ought to be contemplating. They are streets ahead of the Lions in just about every area – with the one notable exception of the midfield.


  • This one is for Charlie!!! :twisted:

  • Comment 1, posted at 22.06.09 15:48:17 by wpw Reply
    wpwAssistant coach
  • @wpw (Comment 1) : RICH’S A TWAT !!! :evil:

  • Comment 2, posted at 22.06.09 15:59:13 by Charlie Reply

    CharlieSuper Rugby player
  • Look, no player is bigger than the team, but Rich has been grinding this organ since last year, irrespective of how Adi played.

    I think the defence will be fine given a few more runs – it wasn’t 1-on-1 defence that was the issue, but the organisation.

    We do miss Butch there though – he scared the daylights out of the oppo.

    Still, Ruan brings different strengths to the park.

  • Comment 3, posted at 22.06.09 16:23:01 by Big Fish Reply
    Big FishAssistant coach
  • @Big Fish (Comment 3) : Agree boet :wink:

  • Comment 4, posted at 22.06.09 16:26:17 by Charlie Reply

    CharlieSuper Rugby player
  • I dont believe Fourie is the answer as he has also played very little rugby over the last 18 months.

    Adi is fine – just dont try to push him to inside centre which is, after openside, the position where most contact is taken in a game.

    It all comes down to tactics – let your defensively strong players take the hits and shield your attacking players until you have the ball.

    NZ do it with Dan Carter – he takes many less tackles than he needs to.

  • Comment 5, posted at 22.06.09 16:35:55 by VinChainSaw Reply
    VinChainSawTeam captain
  • get Burger in to tackle Roberts. Problem solved :-)

  • Comment 6, posted at 22.06.09 16:54:56 by robdylan Reply
    Competition Winner Administrator
    robdylanHead Coach
  • According to JJ Harmse, Burger will replace Brussow for the 2nd test… He also reckons Fourie should come in for Adi but that is prolly just his opinion. :roll:

  • Comment 7, posted at 22.06.09 18:44:36 by wpw Reply
    wpwAssistant coach
  • adi can tackle, ruan can tackle, some people just fall in the grove they never get out of. and the more i read the guy the more i think gavin rich is such.

    with all due respect jacques fourie did nothing on saturday to justify his inclusion in starting 15. and i actually like him more than adi (hope charlie is not reading :mrgreen:

  • Comment 8, posted at 22.06.09 19:19:47 by rekinek Reply
    Competition WinnerCompetition Winner Author
    rekinekTeam captain
  • @rekinek (Comment 8) : But how much time was he given, and he was at inside not outside, with respect to your views, I think that Fourie is a must for Saturday!! Bring Adi back against the Aussies and the Kiwis,when its more attacking rather than defensive but Fourie has to play on Saturday, he is physically imposing and with Div on his inside doing the talking they(lions) will not have a hope. Say what you like Snorman stuffed up big time by hauling Div and not Adi off, Divilliers organises the centre defense and both Adi and Fourie were lost with out him.

  • Comment 9, posted at 23.06.09 06:34:31 by Whindy Reply
    Competition WinnerCompetition Winner
    WhindyCurrie Cup player
  • i agree, fourie on for adi

  • Comment 10, posted at 23.06.09 06:50:17 by JarsonX Reply
    Competition WinnerCompetition WinnerCompetition Winner
    JarsonXAssistant coach

  • Comment 11, posted at 23.06.09 07:36:22 by Charlie Reply

    CharlieSuper Rugby player

Add Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.